A review of taxonomy for health and safety training: A 3 step taxonomy for health and safety training - adequacy, competency, capability.

5 Mar 2019

On the face of it you might think that there is strong compulsion to undertake health and safety training. Several regulations require a certain level of training, qualifications and/or competence to undertake tasks: Radiation protection, gas fitting, mining, diving, driving a car. Health and safety training is of course a legal requirement under section 2(2)(c) of the Health and Safety at Work etc Act, Regulation 13 of the Management of Health and Safety at Work Regulations and the Regulatory Reform (Fire Safety) Order.

The most common offence is “failure to discharge a duty under Section 2(1)”. With reference to all the prosecutions last year under the Health and Safety at Work Act, more than one third cited a breach of Section 2 (1). None specifically referred to 2(2)(c). It seems that the failure of employers to comply with their duties are subsumed by the generality of the Act. No example is currently being made of employers who fail to train their employees. 

Last year the Management Regulations were cited 18 times but none of them were for a breach of Regulation 13. It’s been used in a prosecution three time since 1999. It would seem from this evidence that there is no substantial punishment for failing to train.

And yet a third of judicial decisions explicitly mention that the employer failed to ensure proper training.

More likely, the HSE would use an enforcement notice to deal with inadequate training. Improvement notices such as the one served against Amey in July this year[1] use standard language emphasising that employees must have “adequate information, training and instructions”.

Employers that are prosecuted are typically failing to provide training or the training is inadequate. Adequate is defined as “satisfactory or acceptable in quality or quantity”. Employers therefore need to provide a sufficient amount of relevant training which enable learners to achieve the desired outcome e.g. recognise hazards and understand how to deal with them. Quality, in training terms, means assured or verified training that is consistent, comprehensive and can evidence that learning and understanding has taken place. It must also factor in that managers and employees will need refresher training as it is well known that knowledge can deteriorate over time.   

“Adequate” training is periodical, undertaken in work hours and can be on the job. For example, an experienced operative instructing a less experienced colleague and passing on skills can be a powerful means of ensuring safety in the workplace. HSE guidance accepts that adequate training can be “delivered in-house using the manufacturer's instructions and the background knowledge / skills of more experienced workers and managers”. In a literature review OSHA identified the training intervention work that offered the most positive evidence … targeted site-specific problems[2]. Recording that these events and interventions are occurring can be a problematical compliance issue.

The judgement in the case of Allison v LUL is instructive. “The test for the adequacy of training for the purposes of health and safety is: what training was needed in the light of what the employer ought to have known about the risks arising from the activities of his business. …What the employer ought to have known will be what he would have known if he had carried out a suitable and sufficient risk assessment”. It could be argued that if a control from a risk assessment is to train then failing to do so renders the risk assessment unsuitable and insufficient and is therefore a breach of duty.

The hazards, injuries and health risks common to certain activities should be anticipated by the employer. Training is there to enable employees to understand risks and the methods and techniques to avoid them. This implies a level of knowledge about work activities that some employers and senior managers might not have themselves and they need to reflect on their own competence and training needs.

It’s fair to say that training is one of the most obvious and useful control measures you can have. It can address “unsafe acts” as well as “unsafe conditions” and influence positive behaviours and organisational cultures. Good quality training should empower employees to use more initiative and get more involved in the business of mitigating risk and understand when to stop which is a function of competence. Also, a risk assessment might not reasonably be considered suitable and sufficient if it recommended changes but did not recognise the need to train employees accordingly. In reality, the outcome of a risk assessment must include increased competency for ALL those involved in it. The requirement for a competent person requires people who will increase the knowledge of business risk, which, in turns increases internal competence, develops positive behaviour which in turn reduces risk and improves efficiency.
We can see competency as the next level up in a taxonomy of training after “adequacy”. A good example of this is in the Work at Height Regulations which requires, amongst other things, that people who are being trained to work at height are supervised by someone competent.

The clear indication here is that competency ought to increase with seniority. How many managers are more qualified to do the job than the people they manage? Tapping into this depth of understanding from workers is a management competence and underpins the need to consult and involve stakeholders to ensure that training is suitable, sufficient and adequate. The HSE guidance on training goes on to say: “People should be competent for the work they undertake. Training – along with knowledge, experience and skill – helps develop such competence. It also includes “medical fitness and physical / mental aptitude for the activity”. A competent person, in law[3]  is: “a practicable and reasonable [person] who knows what to look for and how to recognise it when they see it” (and what to do with the knowledge they obtain).

The person is regarded as competent if they have ‘sufficient training and experience or knowledge and other qualities to properly assist the employer to meet his safety obligations’. Competence is therefore a judgement and the responsibility falls to employers to set the criteria required.

Hence for ‘simple situations’ the guidance notes describe that competence may require only:

‘a) An understanding of relevant current best practice;

b) Awareness of the limitations of one’s own experience and knowledge; and

c) The willingness and ability to supplement existing experience and knowledge.’

This is also an important development for the advent of ISO 45001 and what we might term “Next Generation Health and Safety”. The guidance BS 45002 suggests: The organisation should evaluate the effectiveness of actions taken to increase competence. For example, the organisation can ask workers who have received training whether they consider themselves to have achieved the necessary competence to do their work or assess the worker’s competence through role play, peer review or supervision[1]. 

International Network of Safety & Health Practitioner Organisations (INSHPO)[2]  argue[3], that Capability is the next level Beyond Competence. It’s an often-ignored requirement and INSHPO make their case strongly:

 “Competence” has been defined as the ability to transfer and apply knowledge and skills to new situations and environments, consistently applying knowledge and skills to a standard of performance required in the workplace.

By comparison they say, capability is applied theoretical knowledge that underpins practice in occupations and professions and also the industry-specific knowledge and skills that transcend particular workplaces and the tacit knowledge of the workplace.  

Competency is about delivering the present based on the past, while capability is about imagining and being able to realise the future. Capable people make “effective use of knowledge and skills in complex and changing circumstances, including those that may not have been previously experienced”. This is about upskilling people. Capable people are role models for other employees. They can be an employer’s in-house training and development function or an external resource that supplements the organisations learning objectives.  So how do we reach the stage called “Capability?”. Essentially, we need to carry out an assessment of training needs that reflects the risk profile of the organisation.

 INSHPO asserts:

 Capable people have knowledge, skills, self-esteem and values that make them confident in their ability as individuals and in association with others in a diverse and changing society to:

·         take effective and appropriate action

·         explain what they are about

·         live and work effectively with others and

·         continue to learn from their experience.

In conclusion, progressing your workforce to “organisational capability” demands engaging employees in the assessment of needs process, rather than deciding for them what you think they need. Based on the risk profile, and potential emergencies, you should consult with them about their comfort level.

Full article is available on the URL below:-

https://www.hsmsearch.com/page_1014830.asp

Praxis42
Website
Email Us
T: 0870 4464201

Mercury House
Hadleigh Enterprise Park
Crockatt Road
IP7 6RJ
Hadleigh, Suffolk
United Kingdom

Follow:
Facebook   Twitter   LinkedIn

See Praxis42 at Safety & Health Expo 2020

Praxis42 will be exhibiting on Stand SH3860 at Safety & Health Expo 2020, 19-21 May, ExCeL, London, UK

SCHEDULE MEETING
eLearning: Display Screen Equipment - IOSH Approved and CPD Certified
Product

eLearning: Display Screen Equipment - IOSH Approved and CPD Certified

Display Screen Equipment online training from Praxis42 helps to ensure that your organisation remains legally compliant with the Display Screen Equipment Regulations. It’s designed to promote a culture within your organisation that encourages everyone to consider the risks associated with using display screen...

View product page

eLearning: Working at Height - IOSH Approved and CPD Certified
Product

eLearning: Working at Height - IOSH Approved and CPD Certified

Working at Height from Praxis42 aims to help your organisation be legally compliant with the Work at Height Regulations. It’s designed to promote a culture within your business that encourages everyone to consider the risks associated with working at height, and follow safe procedures while undertaking work.

View product page

eLearning: Stress Awareness for Managers - IOSH Approved and CPD Certified
Product

eLearning: Stress Awareness for Managers - IOSH Approved and CPD Certified

Stress Awareness for Managers provides managers with a better understanding of the causes of stress, the positive actions that can be taken to manage stress and their responsibilities as a manager. At the end of the training trainees will be able to:
- Describe the difference between stress and pressure ...

View product page

eLearning: Slips, Trips and Falls - IOSH Approved and CPD Certified
Product

eLearning: Slips, Trips and Falls - IOSH Approved and CPD Certified

The purpose of this course is to make employees aware of the common causes of slips and trips in the workplace and the positive actions they can take towards prevention. At the end of the training trainees will be able to:
- Describe the main causes associated with slip, trips and falls
- Identify typ...

View product page

IOSH Managing Safety - IOSH Approved and CDP Certified
Product

IOSH Managing Safety - IOSH Approved and CDP Certified

This course helps to ensure health and safety requirements are appreciated by managers employed to implement an organisations policy and to enable managers to review their own departmental safety systems, introduce new controls or implement changes as appropriate. Course outcomes include:
- Define ‘hazar...

View product page

eLearning: Manual Handling and Awareness - IOSH Approved and CPD Certified
Product

eLearning: Manual Handling and Awareness - IOSH Approved and CPD Certified

Manual Handling Awareness from Praxis42 helps to ensure that your organisation meet the intent of the Manual Handling Operations Regulations by helping establish a culture where all those involved can input to resolving the issues having received a level of hazard awareness and workplace precaution raining fr...

View product page

eLearning: Food Safety - IOSH Approved and CPD Certified
Product

eLearning: Food Safety - IOSH Approved and CPD Certified

The purpose of this course is to provide the fundamental food hygiene training for all food handlers working in a catering, manufacturing or retail environment where food is prepared, cooked and handled.

View product page

eLearning: Hazardous Substances - IOSH Approved and CPD Certified
Product

eLearning: Hazardous Substances - IOSH Approved and CPD Certified

Hazardous Substances serves to raise the awareness of employers and employees to the hazards associated with the presence and use of chemicals and hazardous substances and the actions that are necessary to control the risks.

View product page

eLearning: Fire Safety Training - IOSH Approved and CPD Certified
Product

eLearning: Fire Safety Training - IOSH Approved and CPD Certified

Online fire safety training and awareness course

View product page

eLearning: Health and Safety Induction - IOSH Approved and CPD Certified
Product

eLearning: Health and Safety Induction - IOSH Approved and CPD Certified

Health and Safety Induction aims to give employees the essential information they need to work safely. The course follows a nationally recognised syllabus where at the end of the training trainees will be able to:
- Understand their responsibilities for health, safety and environment issues in the workpl...

View product page

eLearning:  Fire Marshal and Warden - IOSH Approved and CPD Certified
Product

eLearning: Fire Marshal and Warden - IOSH Approved and CPD Certified

This course makes appointees aware of fire precautions, emergency arrangements and their role in fire safety management. Learnings include:
- Appreciate the components of fire and how fires start
- Identify typical causes and the importance of housekeeping
- Recognise that human actions are the mai...

View product page

eLearning:  Electrical Safety - IOSH Approved and CPD Certified
Product

eLearning: Electrical Safety - IOSH Approved and CPD Certified

Electrical Safety from Praxis42 aims to help your organisation be legally compliant with the Electricity at Work Regulations. It’s designed to promote a culture within your business that encourages everyone to consider the risks associated with working with electricity and carry out safe procedures at all tim...

View product page

eLearning:  EMF Awareness - IOSH Approved and CPD Certified
Product

eLearning: EMF Awareness - IOSH Approved and CPD Certified

EMF Awareness from Praxis42 aims to help organisations to be fully aware of EMF’s, where they occur, the risks involved, and the permissible exposure levels to employees and others, enabling you to appreciate the hazards and risk and take appropriate action. It will help you in demonstrating that your organis...

View product page

eLearning:  Equality and Diversity - IOSH Approved and CPD Certified
Product

eLearning: Equality and Diversity - IOSH Approved and CPD Certified

The course demonstrates the importance of Equality and Diversity in the workplace, introduce the legislation surrounding Equality and Diversity and to provide guidance on the rights and responsibilities of organisations and employees under Equality Law.

View product page

elearning: Aspestos Awareness - IOSH Approved and CPD Certified
Product

elearning: Aspestos Awareness - IOSH Approved and CPD Certified

The Asbestos Awareness course is designed for all levels of employees who may undertake or plan work that may be carried out in buildings and premises or manage buildings and premises. Developed by qualified and experienced health, safety and environment professionals who have many years experience in the del...

View product page

eLearning: Conflict Management - IOSH Approved and CPD Certified
Product

eLearning: Conflict Management - IOSH Approved and CPD Certified

The aim of the course is to make employees aware of how to recognise violence, aggression, harassment and bullying in the workplace and use strategies to reduce the risk of harm. At the end of the training trainees will be able to:
- Recognise what is defined as violence, aggression, harassment and bully...

View product page

eLearning: Driver Awareness - IOSH Approved and CPD Certified
Product

eLearning: Driver Awareness - IOSH Approved and CPD Certified

The purpose of this course is to help employees become more aware of their responsibilities while driving on behalf of their employer and remind them of some of the important aspects of road safety while at work. The ultimate objective is to reinforce safe driving behaviour and identify and influence any poor...

View product page

elearning: Drugs and Alcohol Awareness for Employees - IOSH Approved and CPD Certified
Product

elearning: Drugs and Alcohol Awareness for Employees - IOSH Approved and CPD Certified

Drug and Alcohol Awareness Course for All Employees eLearning aims to give all trainees an understanding of the potential legal, social and financial effects that the misuse of drugs and alcohol can have both on an individual person, and also by consequence on the wider workplace. It also aims to provide stra...

View product page

elearning: Drugs and Alcohol Awareness for Managers - IOSH Approved and CPD Certified
Product

elearning: Drugs and Alcohol Awareness for Managers - IOSH Approved and CPD Certified

Drug and Alcohol Awareness eLearning for Managers aims to help managers understand the impact substance misuse can have on their people at work, their legal position in relation to this, and to provide practical ways to identify and minimise the risks and effects associated with substance misuse.

View product page

eLearning: Fraud Awareness for Managers - IOSH Approved and CPD Certified
Product

eLearning: Fraud Awareness for Managers - IOSH Approved and CPD Certified

Our Fraud Awareness for Managers eLearning helps to equip your management team with the knowledge and understanding of what constitutes fraud and the impact fraud can have on your organisation and the wider economy. It will also provide guidance on how to spot the triggers and situations that can lead to empl...

View product page

eLearning:  Environmental Awareness - IOSH Approved and CPD Certified
Product

eLearning: Environmental Awareness - IOSH Approved and CPD Certified

Environmental Awareness from Praxis42 will explain the main issues that impact the environment and what governments, agencies and individuals are doing to improve these risks. It will also provide the trainee with an awareness of the environment, explain how their actions at work can affect it and what they c...

View product page

eLearning: Anti Bribery - IOSH Approved and CPD Certified
Product

eLearning: Anti Bribery - IOSH Approved and CPD Certified

Our Anti-Bribery eLearning Course serves to educate your employees about the Bribery Act 2010 and its offences. It will help your staff understand what bribery is, in what circumstances it can happen and how your organisations’ policies and procedures can help you avoid it.

View product page

eLearning: Fraud Awareness for Employees - IOSH Approved and CPD Certified
Product

eLearning: Fraud Awareness for Employees - IOSH Approved and CPD Certified

Fraud Awareness for Employees eLearning serves to educate your employees about what constitutes fraud and the impact fraud can have on your organisation and the wider economy. It will also show how all employees have a responsibility to help combat fraud in the workplace and show the trainee how to spot “red ...

View product page

eLearning: Fraud Awareness for Employees - IOSH Approved and CPD Certified
Product

eLearning: Fraud Awareness for Employees - IOSH Approved and CPD Certified

Fraud Awareness for Employees eLearning serves to educate your employees about what constitutes fraud and the impact fraud can have on your organisation and the wider economy. It will also show how all employees have a responsibility to help combat fraud in the workplace and show the trainee how to spot “red ...

View product page

List your business for free

Create a business listing on the SHP directory

Get the SHP newsletter

The latest health and safety news and insights

Close
CONTACT PRAXIS42
* Oops!
* Oops!
* Oops!
* Oops!
* Oops!
I have read, understood and consent to your Privacy Policy
* sorry this is a required field
MESSAGE SENT!

Thanks for using SHP Directory,

Your enquiry has been sent to the selected companies, they will be in contact shortly.